Daily Archives: 14 Mar 2017

From Jesus to his First Followers

54589From Jesus to His First Followers examines to what extent early Christian groups were in continuity or discontinuity with respect to Jesus. Adriana Destro and Mauro Pesce concentrate on the transformation of religious practices. Their anthropological-historical analysis focuses on the relations between discipleship and households, on the models of contact with the supernatural world, and on cohabitation among distinct religious groups. The book highlights how Matthew uses non-Jewish instruments of legitimation, John reformulates religious experiences through symbolized domestic slavery, Paul adopts a religious practice diffused in Roman-Hellenistic environments. The book reconstructs the map of early Christian groups in the Land of Israel and explains their divergences on the basis of an original theory of the local origin of Gospels’ information.

This is the best book on the origins of the Jesus Movement since Crossley’s in 2006.  It contains a number of essays, all previously published (except 7 and 8) and many in places where they may have been fairly inaccessible before collected here.

The contents are divided into four parts:

Jesus’ Strategy: Interstitiality and Conflict

  • 1 The Interstitial Movement of Jesus and the oikos
  • 2 The Conflict of Jesus with the Society of His Time
  • 3 Between Family and Temple: Jesus and Sacrifices
  • 4 Kinship and Movement: Closeness and Distance in John’s Perspective

Religious Practice as Continuity with Jesus

  • 5 The Practice of the Heavenly Journey: The Case of Paul
  • 6 Practices of Contact With the Supernatural: From Jesus to His Followers

Different Groups of Jesus’ Followers, before Christianity

  • 7 The Places of Jesus’ Followers in the Land of Israel: Local Origins of the Gospels’ Sources
  • 8 Divergent Lines of Transmission and Memory: The Passion Narratives in Mark and John
  • 9 A Persecuted and Antagonistic Minority: The Strategy of Matthew
  • 10 ‘Mise en histoire’ and Social Memory: The Politics of the Acts of the Apostles
  • 11 Investigating Domestic Slavery in John

Separation Between Jews and Christians

  • 12 The Separation of the Jesus’ Followers from the Jews: The Case of Burial Space

Index of Names
Thematic Index

The essays are quite engaging and beneficially advance our comprehension of the formative years of the Jesus movement.  The purpose of the collection as described by P. and D.

The essays collected in this volume have in common the attention to Jesus’ and his followers’ style of life and to the social forms that they adopted in order to integrate into society and justify their aims and activities (p. 1).

That brief sentence nicely enunciates the aim of the work.  And it nicely states precisely what the volume achieves.

There are, though, editorial issues with the collection.  ‘Jesus’ is frequently used when the proper form would be “Jesus’s” (cf. p. 4, passim).  Words are misspelled (‘Parte’ on page 5 where it should be ‘Part’; ‘devises’ is used on page 88 instead of the appropriate ‘devices’) and sometimes the grammar is less than proper (again, on page 5, “An analysis of the early processes of memorization leads to recognize the existence of…” should obviously be something like “An analysis of the early processes of memorization leads us (or perhaps, readers) to recognize the existence of…”.  The authors do not speak English as their mother tongue, they speak Italian.  The editorial process should have caught these errors (and several others throughout) and volumes as learned as this one deserve a proper amount of editorial care.  Any future editions of this volume must attend to the necessary task of a close and careful reading through by a native speaker of English.

The linguistic issues aside, this collection of essays is superb.  Our authors can write quite well.  For instance:

What is essential to keep in mind is that the followers of Jesus in the last quarter of the first century had to cope with problems that Jesus had not foreseen and on which had not given instructions (p. 7).

Superior writing in academic circles is writing that makes its point and moves along with all due haste to further points supported by further evidence.  Too much scholarship so tires the reader with repetition and rabbit chasings that by the time the point is arrived at the reader’s interest is worn down to the nub.  All of us should applaud P. and D. for getting to the point!

A further benefit of the present work is the fact that it contains something for everyone.  Are you interested in Reception History?  It is here.  Memory research?  That too is here.  The sociology of early Christianity?  That too is contained herein.  And along the way, as one reads the contents, one constantly discovers flashes of insight on well known stories.  For instance, in their discussion of the transfiguration, D and P write:

Our hypothesis is that the disciples’ participation to [sic! should be ‘in’ – J.W.] the event is narrated to show how Jesus actually involves the disciples in his own experience of contact with the divine (p.  119).

I am bound to recommend this volume, as I am bound to recommend everything that Pesce and Destro write.  They are wonderful scholars and their interdisciplinary approach to New Testament studies is a breath of fresh air in what is far too often a stale and quite dry academic environment.

Comments Off on From Jesus to his First Followers

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Books


Traditional Marriage on Trial: The Supreme Court, Same-Sex Marriage, and the Fate of Secular Argumentation

In the Journal of Church and State.

It’s an interesting read.

Comments Off on Traditional Marriage on Trial: The Supreme Court, Same-Sex Marriage, and the Fate of Secular Argumentation

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Modern Culture


A Brief Note From BNTS

Paul Middleton notes that BNTS plans to

open booking for the 2017 conference in Maynooth (31st Aug-2nd Sept) next week.

Stay tuned.

Comments Off on A Brief Note From BNTS

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in BNTS


SCSC Call for Papers

Sixteenth Century Society and Conference – 14 March 2017


The Sixteenth Century Society and Conference (SCSC) is now accepting proposals for individual presentation submissions and complete panels for its 2017 annual conference, to be held 26-29 October 2017 at Hyatt Regency Hotel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The deadline for proposals is April 15, 2017. In this year celebrating the 500th anniversary of Martin Luther’s “Ninety-Five Theses,” the SCSC will meet in Milwaukee, a city with a proud German and Lutheran heritage. As always, we will accept papers on any topic within the “long sixteenth century,” not just those on Germany, or Lutheran subjects.

Within four weeks after the April 15 deadline, the Program Committee will notify all those who submitted proposals. The conference will once again host poster sessions. In addition to standard panels, the organizing committee will be accepting proposals for four types of alternate panels:

• Workshop Option A: Discussion of pre-circulated papers in a workshop format (limit of 4 participants).

• Workshop Option B: Analysis of thorny translation/paleography questions; pre-circulation not required (limit of 3 participants).

Workshop Option C: Examination of a big issue or question with brief comments from presenters and lively audience participation (similar to roundtables with more audience participation; limit of 4 participants)

•Roundtables sponsored by affiliated societies.

Questions about formats should be directed to: We also welcome proposals for roundtables sponsored by scholarly societies that are affiliated with the SCSC. Abstracts (up to 250 words in length) for individual presentations and complete panels must be submitted online by 15 April 2017 at:

The SCSC, founded to promote scholarship on the early modern era (ca. 1450 – ca. 1660), actively encourages the participation of international scholars as well as the integration of younger colleagues into the academic community. The SCSC is a not-for-profit scholarly organization. It receives no governmental or institutional funding. In order to participate in this conference, delegates or their sponsoring institution/organization will need to fund their own travel and lodging expenses in addition to a $195 per delegate registration fee or $100 student fee ($205 and $110 respectively after 1 September 2017). The registration fee is used to pay for conference facilities and general events. By paying the fee, delegates become members in the SCSC and receive the Sixteenth Century Journal. For more information, please contact:

Kathleen Comerford, SCSC Vice President and Program Chair


Comments Off on SCSC Call for Papers

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Modern Culture


Colloque: “La vie tout entière est pénitence…”

Comments Off on Colloque: “La vie tout entière est pénitence…”

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Conferences


#ConfessYourUnpopularOpinion – #PiDay is STUPID

We need Zwingli Day (January 1… or Oct 11… either one).  The fact that there isn’t one yet is the greatest proof of the Total Depravity of modern culture.



Comments Off on #ConfessYourUnpopularOpinion – #PiDay is STUPID

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Modern Culture


Luther’s Pacifism

By a facebook friend-

Comments Off on Luther’s Pacifism

Posted by on 14 Mar 2017 in Luther